Visa Waiver Program: Waivers, Minors, and Removal Procedures
Vera v. Att’y Gen., 672 F.3d 187 (3d Cir. 2012).
Substance of the Case:
This case examines the Visa Waiver Program (VWP), which allows nationals of certain countries to visit the United States without a visa for up to 90 days. However, visitors must waive their right to contest removal (deportation), except in asylum cases. The petitioner, Jordana Vera, an Argentinian national, entered the U.S. under the VWP as a minor in 2000 but overstayed her permitted period. Years later, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) initiated removal proceedings. Vera argued her removal was invalid because:
The government could not produce a signed waiver.
She was a minor when she entered and thus incapable of waiving her rights.
She was denied due process.
Outcome:
- The court rejected Vera’s claims and upheld her removal order. It ruled that:
- By entering under the VWP, Vera was presumed to have signed the waiver as it is a mandatory condition of entry.
- Vera could not prove she suffered prejudice from the alleged absence of a waiver, as her removal would have occurred regardless.
- The VWP’s conditions were lawful, even for minors, and necessary for efficient enforcement of immigration laws.
Detailed Analysis:
Facts:
Entry Under the VWP:
- Vera entered the U.S. at age 12 with her father in 2000 under the Visa Waiver Program, which requires all entrants to waive their rights to contest removal except for asylum claims.
- She overstayed the 90-day period and remained in the U.S. for over a decade.
Discovery and Removal:
- In 2011, DHS officers discovered Vera during the arrest of her brother. DHS issued a removal order without a hearing, as required under VWP rules.
Claims:
- Vera argued that her removal violated due process because the government failed to provide a signed waiver.
- She further claimed that, as a minor at the time of entry, she could not knowingly waive her rights.
Court’s Analysis:
Waiver Requirement:
- The court ruled that the government was entitled to a presumption that Vera signed the required waiver because the VWP mandates its execution before admission.
- The lack of a signed waiver in DHS records did not rebut this presumption.
Minor Status and Waiver Validity:
- While the court acknowledged Vera’s minor status, it concluded she could not show that her age rendered the waiver invalid or caused her prejudice. The court noted that denying entry to minors under the VWP would undermine the program’s efficiency.
Due Process and Prejudice:
- Even if Vera’s waiver was invalid, the court found no prejudice because her removal was inevitable. Without the waiver, Vera would have been denied entry at the border.
- The court emphasized that the VWP’s streamlined removal process is integral to managing the program, which processes millions of entrants annually.
Conclusion:
The court upheld the removal order, stressing that the VWP requires participants to accept its conditions, including waiving rights to contest removal. It highlighted the importance of maintaining the program’s efficiency and noted that Vera’s long overstay did not entitle her to additional procedural protections.
Key Takeaways:
- Mandatory Waiver: Entering under the VWP requires a waiver of most procedural rights, and courts presume compliance with this requirement.
- No Special Treatment for Minors: The court did not exempt minors from the waiver requirement, emphasizing that admitting minors without conditions would undermine the VWP.
- Prejudice Requirement: In due process claims, individuals must demonstrate significant prejudice caused by alleged violations. Vera failed to meet this standard.
Implications:
This case underscores the strict enforcement of the Visa Waiver Program and the limited legal options available to those who overstay their entry period.
Let’s Get Started
Your legal challenges deserve personalized attention and innovative solutions. Contact Oware Justice Advocates PC today for a consultation and take the first step toward resolution and peace of mind.
355 South Teller Street, Suite 204,
Lakewood, CO 80226
(Visits to the office are strictly by appointment only)
303-514-6589
