How Does a Shoplifting Arrest Affect an Asylum Case?
My friend, who is an asylum seeker, was arrested for shoplifting $80 from Walmart. He was released after fingerprinting and given a court date. At court, the case was dismissed, but he had provided a false name and date of birth due to his limited English skills. Will this arrest and false information affect his asylum case? Can the record be removed before the final asylum hearing?
Expert Answer:
When an asylum seeker is arrested and provides incorrect information, even unintentionally, it can raise concerns that may impact their asylum case. Here’s a breakdown of how such incidents can affect the case and steps to address the situation.
1. Does This Incident Affect the Asylum Case?
- Credibility Issues: U.S. asylum law places significant weight on the credibility of the applicant (INA § 208(b)(1)(B)(iii)). Providing a false name or date of birth can raise questions about the applicant’s honesty, even if it was due to a language barrier.
- Criminal Records: Although the shoplifting charge was dismissed, the arrest and fingerprints may still appear in official records. Even dismissed charges can be relevant to immigration proceedings under the “good moral character” standard (INA § 101(f)).
2. Will This Show on Their Record?
- Yes, arrest records, including dismissed cases, may still appear in FBI or other law enforcement databases.
- Immigration authorities, such as USCIS or immigration judges, can access these records.
3. Steps to Address the Situation
Step 1: Obtain Arrest and Court Records
- Request all police reports, fingerprint records, and court documents to confirm the case dismissal.
- Ensure these records clearly indicate that no conviction occurred.
Step 2: Consult an Immigration Attorney
- Misrepresentation of identity can be a serious issue, even if unintentional.
- An immigration attorney can help present the case and explain mitigating circumstances, such as language barriers and lack of understanding.
Step 3: Be Honest and Transparent During the Asylum Process
- Prepare a detailed explanation of the situation, including the language challenges and circumstances leading to the mistake.
- During the asylum interview or hearing, emphasize the lack of malicious intent and provide supporting documentation, including proof of dismissal.
Step 4: Consider Expungement (if applicable)
- In some jurisdictions, dismissed charges can be expunged or sealed.
- While an expungement does not erase the record entirely for immigration purposes, it may help mitigate the impact.
- Consult a criminal attorney with experience in expungements.
4. Legal Foundations and Guidance
- Immigration and Nationality Act (INA): Governs asylum eligibility, credibility requirements, and moral character considerations.
- USCIS Policy Manual: Offers insights into how criminal conduct and credibility issues are assessed in asylum cases (USCIS Policy Manual – Asylum).
- Federal Regulations (8 CFR § 208.13): Outline eligibility criteria for asylum, including credibility assessments.
5. Final Note
While the shoplifting arrest and incorrect information could impact the asylum case, these challenges can be addressed by gathering strong evidence, being transparent, and seeking legal guidance. Early action is key to mitigating potential issues before the final asylum hearing.
6. Additional Resources
Let’s Get Started
Your legal challenges deserve personalized attention and innovative solutions. Contact Oware Justice Advocates PC today for a consultation and take the first step toward resolution and peace of mind.
355 South Teller Street, Suite 204,
Lakewood, CO 80226
(Visits to the office are strictly by appointment only)
303-514-6589
