News & Insights

I-589 In General

How to Gather Strong Evidence for an LGBTQ+ Asylum Case Without Witness Statements

February 12, 2025

What Evidence Can I Submit to Support My Asylum Case Based on LGBTQ+ Persecution if I Don’t Have Witness Statements?

Expert Answer:

Applying for asylum based on your sexual orientation or membership in a particular social group requires presenting compelling evidence to demonstrate your fear of persecution. While witness statements can be helpful, they are not the only form of evidence. Below are steps and types of evidence that can significantly strengthen your case, even if you are unable to obtain personal statements from others.

1. Personal Affidavit

Your affidavit (personal statement) is the cornerstone of your asylum application. It should detail your personal experiences, fears, and the persecution you’ve faced.

How to Write an Effective Affidavit:
  • Describe Your Identity: Explain your sexual orientation and how this puts you at risk in your home country.
  • Detail Persecution or Threats: Include specific incidents where you were targeted, such as violence, threats, or harassment. Be as detailed as possible, including dates, locations, and individuals involved.
  • Fear of Returning: Clearly articulate why you believe you would face harm or persecution if you were to return.
  • Impact of Persecution: Describe the emotional, physical, and social toll these incidents have had on you.

2. Evidence of Country Conditions

Country condition reports can provide critical context and corroborate your claims of systemic persecution of LGBTQ+ individuals.

Key Resources:

3. Documentary Evidence

Even without witness statements, you can provide various forms of supporting evidence.

Evidence of Persecution:
  • Medical Records: If you were physically harmed, medical records documenting your injuries can serve as evidence.
  • Police Reports: If you reported any incidents to the authorities, include copies of police reports, even if no action was taken (or you were mistreated).
  • Social Media Threats: Screenshots of threats or hate messages directed at you on social media platforms can be strong evidence.
  • Photos or Videos: Any visual evidence of attacks, protests, or hostile environments targeting LGBTQ+ individuals.
Evidence of Discrimination:
  • Employment or Housing Records: Documents showing that you were fired or denied housing due to your sexual orientation.
  • Legal Records: Copies of discriminatory laws or policies targeting LGBTQ+ individuals in your home country.

4. Expert Testimony and Letters

Expert opinions and letters can provide authoritative support for your claims.

Sources for Expert Testimony:
  • LGBTQ+ Advocacy Groups – Organizations like OutRight Action International or Immigration Equality may provide support or letters attesting to the dangers faced by LGBTQ+ individuals in your country.
  • Academics or Researchers – Letters from professors or researchers specializing in LGBTQ+ rights in your region.
  • Therapists or Counselors – If you have sought therapy due to trauma related to your persecution, your therapist can provide a statement about your mental health and its connection to your experiences.

5. Building Credibility

USCIS and immigration courts place great importance on your credibility as an applicant.

How to Build Credibility:
  • Consistency: Ensure your testimony aligns with the evidence you submit.
  • Preparation: Work with an experienced attorney or advocate to prepare for your asylum interview or hearing.
  • Honesty: Be truthful, even if certain details are embarrassing or difficult to discuss.

6. Additional Steps

If you cannot obtain certain evidence, explain why. For instance, if it is too dangerous to contact people in your home country or if witnesses fear retaliation, include this in your affidavit.

Conclusion

Even without witness statements, you can build a strong asylum case based on LGBTQ+ persecution by gathering a wide range of evidence, including personal affidavits, country condition reports, documentary evidence, and expert testimony. Organizations like Immigration Equality and other LGBTQ+ advocacy groups can provide valuable guidance and resources. By presenting a comprehensive and consistent case, you can demonstrate that your fear of returning to your home country is well-founded.

Let’s Get Started

Your legal challenges deserve personalized attention and innovative solutions. Contact Oware Justice Advocates PC today for a consultation and take the first step toward resolution and peace of mind.

355 South Teller Street, Suite 204,
Lakewood, CO 80226
(Visits to the office are strictly by appointment only)

303-514-6589

scrolltop